Civil Discourse Through Debate

A key value of St. Mark’s is the “responsibility of defending one’s own ideas and of respecting the views of others," a principle so fundamental to the School’s mission that it is written into the Statement of Purpose. Civil discourse is practiced every day in conversations and interactions across the Harkness table and around campus, as boys learn to form their own ideas, share those ideas with others, and respect others who express different ideas.  

For Debate Coach Tim Mahoney, civil discourse is at the heart of everything his program espouses: “The only thing I try to teach on day one of the debate class is a lesson we come back to throughout a student’s debate career: Debate is about listening respectfully and responding respectfully." 

For decades, the St. Mark’s debate program has taught and practiced civil discourse while also growing from a campus club into a national powerhouse. In that time, its signature tournament has grown with it, all while teaching Marksmen to be good hosts. 

The School’s Heart of Texas Invitational Debate Tournament has evolved from a local event into a premier competition, attracting some of the nation’s top debaters to campus each year. It has become such a significant event that St. Mark’s turns it into a student holiday so that every corner of campus can be utilized. This year, the tournament welcomed more than 450 competitors and 200 judges and coaches representing more than 50 schools, who participated in a variety of debate formats. 

In addition to competing, Marksmen spent the weekend serving as hosts, welcoming visitors and helping guests navigate campus. As Debate Coach Tim Mahoney puts it, “Our motto for the tournament is ‘Protect the Campus - Be Good Hosts’ with the parenthetical ‘if we win a few debates that’s great too.’” 

That balance of excellence and hospitality reflects the story of the program itself. While debate has existed in one form or another since the 1960s, it became a national powerhouse under David Baker, who joined St. Mark’s as debate coach in 1984 and now teaches history at the School after serving as Director of Admissions until 2025. Shortly after Baker’s arrival, the program began collecting national titles. Marksmen won the National Forensic League’s national policy debate championship in 1990, the Montgomery Bell Academy Championship in 1989 and 1990, and the Texas Forensic Association State Championship in 1990. 

Baker also founded the National Debate Coaches Association in 1993, helping build a national organization dedicated to supporting coaches and strengthening debate education. In recognition of his impact, one of the NDCA's annual awards is named the David P. Baker Cup.

“High school debaters compete in an activity that might best be described as full-contact social studies,” Baker once said. “Students are required to defend both sides of the resolution during a typical weekend tournament. Exposure to opposition arguments gives these students a thorough understanding of the complexity of issues facing our country and the world."

While the program found national success, Baker noted the lack of a national-level high school debate competition in Dallas. The St. Mark’s Invitational had existed mainly for local and regional schools, until Baker decided to expand its aim. By the late 1980s, it had become the Heart of Texas Invitational and began attracting dozens and then hundreds of schools.  

That legacy has continued under Mahoney, who began his tenure around the turn of the century and has now led the program for 27 years and counting. In that time, Marksmen have racked up numerous wins at the national level, including a 2002 National Forensic League national championship. The tournament has grown as well. Under Mahoney’s leadership, it sustained its national prominence and expanded into virtual and hybrid competition, bringing hundreds of students together annually from across the country. In 2012, the Invitational earned the National Debate Coaches Association’s Tournament of the Year award. 

Today, the tournament reflects both strands of that legacy: excellence in competition and excellence in hospitality. Mahoney measures each tournament’s success by both the performance of St. Mark’s debaters and the experience had by their visitors. 

“It’s important that the boys understand that tournaments don’t happen by magic. A lot of people have to work really hard to create a good tournament experience,” said Mahoney. “After the tournament, we don’t just debrief the debates; we assess how we did at being good hosts and talk about shared responsibility.” 

On the competition side, several St. Mark’s debaters reached elimination rounds in their respective areas. The results were especially notable because the tournament included five of the nation’s top ten policy debate teams, giving Marksmen valuable experience against elite competition. 

But for Mahoney, debate is about so much more than researching positions and articulating arguments: “Debate teaches students skills they’ll use throughout their lives: how to speak with integrity, consider different perspectives, and lead with both conviction and humility.” 
Back
    • Current and former debate team members host the 2026 Heart of Texas Debate Tournament.

    • Mahoney (center) with members of the 2002 debate team.

    • Baker (center) with members of the 1989 debate team.

    • The St. Mark's debate team competes at the 2023 Heart of Texas Invitational.

St. Mark’s School of Texas

10600 Preston Road
Dallas, Texas 75230
214-346-8000

About Us

St. Mark’s School of Texas is a private, nonsectarian college-preparatory boys’ day school for students in grades 1 through 12, located in Dallas, Texas. St. Mark’s aims to prepare young men to assume leadership and responsibility in a competitive and changing world.

St. Mark’s does not discriminate in the administration of its admission and education policies on the basis of race, color, religion, sexual orientation, or national or ethnic origin.